GreenCarGuide.co.uk

Menu

Fiat 124 Spider Review

Fiat 124 Spider

Fiat 124 Spider

By Paul Clarke

ECO FACTS

Model/Engine size: Fiat 124 Spider Lusso Plus 1.4 MultiAir Turbo 140hp

Fuel: Petrol

Fuel economy combined: 44.1 mpg

Green Car Guide rating: 10/10

INTRODUCTION

The Fiat 124 Spider offers fun, economy (50mpg in real-life driving) and affordability, and of course the car’s light weight is key to its success.

SUMMARY 

  • Excellent fun to drive
  • Can return 50mpg in real-life driving
  • Shares its base with the Mazda MX-5
  • Fiat has different styling, a 1.4 turbo engine, and softer suspension

BACKGROUND

We’ve already tested the Mazda MX-5 2-litre and we’ve driven the 1.5-litre MX-5, and we love both cars. The Fiat 124 Spider has now been launched, based on the same platform. So how does the Fiat compare?

Fiat 124 SpiderFiat 124 Spider

Click on images to enlarge and for slideshow

DESIGN & ENGINEERING

Although the Fiat 124 Spider shares its platform with the Mazda MX-5, one key difference is that the MX-5 comes with 1.5-litre or 2.0-litre non-turbo engines, whereas the Fiat comes with a 1.4-litre turbo unit. The Fiat’s suspension is also softer. And of course externally both cars have different styling approaches, along with individual treatment in the interiors. We’ve always thought that the MX-5 looks excellent; when we saw the initial press photos of the 124 Spider, we didn’t think it looked as good. However the car actually looks better in the metal. Although it has to be said that we personally wouldn’t choose the brown colour of our press car…

Fiat 124 SpiderFiat 124 Spider

Click on images to enlarge and for slideshow

FIAT 124 SPIDER DRIVING EXPERIENCE

Here at Green Car Guide we’re looking for cars that combine efficiency with a great driving experience on public roads at speeds where you won’t lose your licence. The Fiat 124 Spider delivers on both of these objectives.

The Fiat is small and lightweight (with a kerb weight of 1050kg – the same as the 1.5-litre MX-5, and slightly lighter than the 1075kg 2-litre MX-5) and it has a very low centre of gravity. It has sharp, direct and responsive steering. It’s rear-wheel drive, so the rear wheels put the power down, and the front wheels can focus on steering rather than transmitting power. The 1.4-litre turbo petrol engine is responsive when it’s operating at more than 2000rpm, and the six-speed manual gearbox is slick. There’s also an excellent driving position, even though the steering wheel has no reach adjustment. This is the same on the MX-5, in order to avoid added complexity, weight and cost.

So how does all this translate to the driving experience in real-life? Point the Spider down a twisting Welsh B-road and it feels light, agile and very well balanced. Grip levels are almost perfectly judged – there’s just the right amount of grip to make every outing in the 124 Spider a rewarding experience. You can carve through corners in the dry with delicacy yet also with confidence, but in wet or greasy conditions, you can have as much fun with the rear end as you want. It’s worth noting that there’s no limited slip-differential on this model (which does feature on the 2-litre MX-5).

Very small inputs to the steering result in instant response from the front tyres and from the rest of the car, with satisfying changes of direction. The turbo engine provides more performance than you might expect from a 1.4-litre, even with two occupants. And the gear lever moves quickly and smoothly around the box, making frequent changes a pleasurable experience.

Very few modern cars provide this sort of rewarding, direct interaction between driver, car and road, due to their weight and their insulation from the outside world.

The Fiat also manages to combine classic rear-wheel drive sports car handling with supple suspension. The MX-5, with its firmer suspension, results in less roll when pushing on through corners. However in the real world, rather than on a smooth race track, during daily use on the UK’s battered roads, the Fiat does a good job of providing a comfortable ride.

So what about the turbo (Fiat) v non-turbo (Mazda) argument? Try and accelerate under 2000rpm in the turbo Fiat and there’s very little response. But on the flip side, our test route in North Wales for the 124 Spider took in many of the same roads as our MX-5 test, and whereas the 2-litre Mazda struggled to accelerate up some hills with two occupants on board, the Fiat had no such problems. Although the Fiat is slightly down on power compared to the 2-litre MX-5, it has more torque – 240 Nm compared to the 2-litre MX-5’s 200 Nm, and the 1.5-litre MX-5’s 150 Nm. So if you want linear throttle response, go for the MX-5; if you can live with poor response at low revs in order to get more torque at higher revs, then go for the Fiat.

In terms of the interior, the dashboard is modern, stylish and functional, and the infomedia system is essentially the same as that in the MX-5, which means that it’s very good, and thanks to having a BMW iDrive-like rotary controller near the gear lever, it’s so much better than the majority of systems that are purely touch screens, which we believe are not a sensible idea in most cars, but certainly don’t work well in sports cars on bumpy roads.

There’s a useful reversing camera, and as with the MX-5, you even get two cup holders, which sit between the two seat backs. The boot is an acceptable size for a small two-seater sports car.

The soft top is very quick and easy to take down or put up, but one issue to be aware of, along with virtually all soft tops around this price point, is that there’s lots of wind and road noise at motorway speeds.

Fiat 124 SpiderFiat 124 Spider

Click on images to enlarge and for slideshow

FIAT 124 SPIDER ECONOMY AND EMISSIONS

The official combined fuel economy of the Fiat 124 Spider is 44.1mpg, with emissions of 148g/km CO2 (the official combined fuel economy of the 2-litre MX-5 is 40.9mpg, with emissions of 161g/km CO2; 47.1mpg/139g/km CO2 for the 1.5-litre MX-5). So what did we get in real life? Well, at a constant 50mph on the roadworks stretch of the M6 motorway that goes on for miles and miles, the 124 Spider recorded an indicated 66.9mpg. For a car that’s as fun to drive as the 124 Spider, the ability to achieve almost 70mpg at a constant 50mph is a highly impressive feat. This is due to the car’s light weight, its small frontal area, and of course its efficient engine. At 70mph on the motorway it averaged 49.6mpg (48.0mpg for the MX-5) – again, a very good result. Overall, after a week of mixed driving, the Fiat averaged 41.5mpg. We averaged 40.3mpg in the 2-litre MX-5, suggesting that the Fiat is slightly more economical in real-life, so reflecting its official figures.

Fiat 124 SpiderFiat 124 Spider

Click on images to enlarge and for slideshow

PRICE AND MODEL RANGE

The Fiat 124 Spider Lusso Plus 1.4 MultiAir Turbo 140hp costs £23,295. The ‘Magnetic Bronze’ metallic paint of our test car cost £500. There are three trim levels; Classica, Lusso, Lusso Plus. Prices of the 124 Spider are broadly similar to those of the MX-5.

Fiat 124 SpiderFiat 124 Spider

Click on images to enlarge and for slideshow

CONCLUSION

The Fiat 124 Spider is exactly the sort of car that Green Car Guide has stood for over the last 10 years. It’s excellent to drive, yet it can also be economical. The key to achieving both of these elements is the light weight of the car. Although there has been much talk in the industry about lightweighting, most cars over recent years have in fact been getting heavier. The Fiat 124 Spider weighs just 1050kg, which means it has great handling, and its relatively small engine gives it good performance. Combined with the car’s small frontal area, it is genuinely efficient, as our achievement of almost 70mpg at 50mph shows.

But what about the key question we have to address? Which is better, the Mazda MX-5 or the Fiat 124 Spider? Well, not surprisingly, both are very similar. The main differences are that the Fiat has slightly more retro looks, a turbo engine, and softer suspension. In terms of the looks, this is completely subjective. If you’re intending to drive on the limit most of the time, then the firmer suspension of the MX-5 will provide more reassuring race car-like handling. However as an all-round car for daily use on the UK’s bumpy and pot-holed roads, then the Fiat will be easier to live with. The turbo engine also provides good responses, as long as you keep it above 2000rpm. So both the Fiat and the Mazda deliver what we want – ie. they’re great to drive and efficient – but just in slightly different ways. Both achieve something really important – they’re rewarding drivers’ cars at speeds that won’t end up with you losing your licence.

The Mazda MX-5 was awarded a Green Car Guide rating of 10 out of 10, and so it’s not really possible to award the Fiat 124 Spider anything different – so it also enjoys a 10 out of 10 rating.

Paul Clarke

Paul Clarke, Editor, Green Car Guide

CAR FACTS AND FIGURES – Fiat 124 Spider Lusso Plus 1.4 MultiAir Turbo 140hp DATA 

Fuel economy extra urban: 55.4 mpg

Fuel economy urban: 33.2 mpg

Test economy: 41.5 mpg

CO2 emissions: 148 g/km

Green rating: VED band F

Weight: 1050 kg

Company car tax liability (2015/16): tbc%

Price: £23,295

Insurance group: 26

Power: 140 hp

Max speed: 134 mph

0-62mph: 7.5 seconds

Torque: 240 Nm

OTHER FIAT REVIEWS >>

REVIEWS OF GREEN DRIVERS’ CARS >>

bmw i8

1. BMW I8

The BMW i8 is the world’s first plug-in hybrid supercar with a three-cylinder petrol engine, and it combines a top speed of 155mph with an official economy figure of 135mpg and emissions of 49g/km CO2.

Read more about the BMW i8

 

 

Mazda MX-5

2. MAZDA MX-5

The Mazda MX-5 is lightweight and efficient; the 2-litre model is excellent, but the 1.5-litre is slightly lighter again, and so even better on twisty Welsh B-roads…

Read more about the Mazda MX-5

 

 

Subaru BRZ

3. TOYOTA GT86/SUBARU BRZ

The Toyota GT86 and Subaru BRZ are two of the most fun cars that money can buy, and they’re also a lot more efficient than a V8 supercar…

Read more about the Toyota GT86/Subaru BRZ

 

caterham 160

4. CATERHAM 160

Can a Caterham 160 with a design that’s almost 60 years old, skinny tyres and a three-cylinder, 660cc, 80bhp engine really offer a fun and economical driving experience? You may be surprised at the answer…

Read more about the Caterham 160

 

Lotus Elise

5. LOTUS ELISE

Lightweight, mid-engined, direct driving experience, and, yes, efficient – that’s the Lotus Elise…

Read more about the Lotus Elise

 

Porsche Panamera Hybrid

6. PORSCHE PANAMERA S E-HYBRID

The Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid has an official combined economy figure of 91.1mpg, yet it also has a top speed of 167mph. You certainly won’t see both at the same time, and you’ll probably never see 91.1mpg, but you can benefit from low company car tax and a great driving experience…

Read more about the Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid

 

Porsche Cayenne S Hybrid

7. PORSCHE CAYENNE S HYBRID

Green Car Guide exists to look for cars that are great to drive and also efficient – this combination doesn’t happen very often, but the Porsche Cayenne S Hybrid hits the mark.

Read more about the Porsche Cayenne S Hybrid

 

Tesla Model S P85D

8. TESLA MODEL S P85D

The Tesla Model S is probably the biggest revolution in motoring in the last 100 years, as Tesla has appeared from nowhere and produced an amazing all-electric sports saloon with a range of 300 miles, 0-60mph acceleration in 3.1 seconds – and it can even seat up to 7 people.

Read more about the Tesla Model S P85D

 

BMW i3

9. BMW I3

The BMW i3 is a rear-wheel drive pure electric or range-extended family hatchback, complete with BMW driving genes.

Read more about the BMW i3

 

 

MINI 5-door Hatch

10. MINI

The latest incarnation of the MINI delivers fun, character and refinement – along with performance and economy in the case of the 2-litre SD 5-door Hatch.

Read more about the MINI 2-litre SD 5-door Hatch